Shigaraki vs Todoroki Tsumamare Keychains: Which to Pick?

The short answer: pick by character, not by spec sheet

Both the Shigaraki and Todoroki Tsumamare keychains come from COSPA and share the same listed height, so the supplied records don't give you a size-based reason to choose one over the other. The real decision is which character you want on your keys, bag, or shelf—and whether the price difference matters to you.

This comparison sticks to what the product records actually confirm. Where a detail isn't listed, I'll say so rather than guess.

What the records confirm for each keychain

• Shoto Todoroki Tsumamare Keychain TV Anime - My Hero Academia: Authentic Shoto Todoroki Tsumamare Keychain from COSPA in Japan; dimensions approx. H60mm. Confirms the maker, origin, and the only listed size figure, so you know what you're comparing.

  

• Tomura Shigaraki Tsumamare Keychain TV Anime - My Hero Academia: Authentic Tomura Shigaraki Tsumamare Keychain from COSPA in Japan; dimensions approx. H60mm. Same maker and same listed height as the Todoroki version, which removes size as a deciding factor.

  

Price and character appeal side by side

• Shigaraki Tsumamare keychain: Catalog price USD 7.15 (comparison price USD 11.00). A villain-focused pick at the lower catalog price of the two.
• Todoroki Tsumamare keychain: Catalog price USD 8.03 (comparison price USD 11.00). A hero-focused pick that costs slightly more at catalog price.
• Shared ground: Both are authentic COSPA items from Japan with the same approx. H60mm listed dimension. Neither record lists extra accessories, materials, or care instructions.

What the specs don't tell you

The supplied records list only the height and the COSPA origin. They don't confirm the material, the attachment style, the weight, or whether the keychain is suitable for a particular age group. If those details matter to you—for example, if you're buying for a child or plan to hang it on a heavy bag—treat them as unconfirmed rather than assuming.

Because both keychains share the same listed height, you can't use size to break the tie. The decision comes down to which character fits your collection and whether the small price gap influences you.

How to decide between the two

• Choose Shigaraki if...: You want a villain-side My Hero Academia keychain and prefer the lower catalog price of the two.
• Choose Todoroki if...: You want a hero-side keychain and don't mind paying slightly more at catalog price.
• Choose both if...: You're building a hero-and-villain set and want the pair; the shared height makes them easy to display together.